Verse study
Psalm 78:20
20 Behold, he struck the rock, so that waters gushed out, and streams overflowed. Can he give bread also? Will he provide meat for his people?”
Meaning & historical commentary
The water has just come out of the rock, and the crowd's question is a jab at the very miracle they are drinking from. In the wilderness a people who had only just walked out of Egypt knew how close water and food were to failing, so their question is not idle curiosity but a challenge that God can provide for their daily needs as well as their thirst. Their challenge echoes the scene in Numbers 20:11, where Moses strikes the rock and water pours out, a story the psalmist assumes his audience carries in memory. The psalm's Israelites are not doubting that God can act; they are doubting that he will keep feeding them, which is why the next verse turns the question into anger.