Verse study
Proverbs 11:24
24 There is one who scatters, and increases yet more. There is one who withholds more than is appropriate, but gains poverty.
Meaning & historical commentary
In a largely agrarian society where wealth was measured in grain, oil, flocks and land, the sage notices a paradox that anyone who sold seed or kept a granary would have seen firsthand: the man who scatters his seed in the field, or spends freely, ends up with more, while the one who clutches what he has to himself drifts into want. Scholars differ on whether the first clause refers to generous giving to the needy or to the sowing that yields a harvest, but the second clause is clear enough, since the one who holds back "more than is appropriate" finds poverty waiting. The saying bears on village life, where the surplus of one season's yield was the thing a household had to decide whether to store, share or sell.