Verse study
Numbers 14:41
41 Moses said, “Why now do you disobey the commandment of Yahweh, since it shall not prosper?
Meaning & historical commentary
Moses speaks here to a camp that has just swung from weeping to a rash attempt to storm the hill country on its own, and his question carries the force of a shepherd catching a flock before it walks off a cliff. The congregation has already tried to replace Moses and Aaron and return to Egypt, so this sudden eagerness to go up looks like repentance but is really more defiance, an attempt to take the initiative without the God who has just refused to go with them. Moses's rebuke turns on the claim that such an undertaking cannot succeed, since the Amalekites and Canaanites waiting in the hills are not defeated by a people whom Yahweh has disowned for this campaign.