Verse study
Mark 9:28
28 When he had come into the house, his disciples asked him privately, “Why couldn’t we cast it out?”
Meaning & historical commentary
The disciples wait until they are alone in a house to ask the question that has been eating at them since the failed exorcism in the crowd, and that privacy matters. Having just been humiliated before a crowd of scribes and onlookers, they are embarrassed and want an explanation away from public view, so their question is one of wounded pride as much as curiosity. Jesus answers in the next verse with a point about prayer and fasting, which is the real payoff of this scene.