Verse study
Mark 9:11
11 They asked him, saying, “Why do the scribes say that Elijah must come first?”
Meaning & historical commentary
The disciples are coming down from the mountain of transfiguration still reeling, and their question reflects a real expectation of the day: the scribes, the trained interpreters of Torah, taught that Elijah had to come before the messianic age could arrive. The question assumes the prophecy of Malachi, which closes the Hebrew prophets with the promise that Elijah would return before "the great and terrible day," so the disciples are asking why the experts insist on a sequence they have just watched unfold with Elijah standing beside Jesus. Their puzzlement is sharpened by the command to keep silence about what they saw, since they cannot reconcile a glorified Son of Man with a restoration they had been taught to expect in a particular order.