Verse study

Mark 8:19

19 When I broke the five loaves among the five thousand, how many baskets full of broken pieces did you take up?” They told him, “Twelve.”
World English Bible

Meaning & historical commentary

In a disciples' boat crossing the lake, Jesus' question turns on the leftover bread: he asks them to recall the figures from the two feedings, and the answer, twelve and then seven, is the reply that exposes their forgetfulness. The baskets are small hand-carried containers, the sort a traveler or a peasant carried for food, and the "broken pieces" are the scraps left after the crowds were fed, so the disciples are being asked to recall not a miracle in the abstract but a concrete tally of leftovers they themselves gathered up. Their own bookkeeping, in other words, already holds the answer to the anxiety they voiced over having only one loaf.

Open in Interactive Book →