Verse study

Mark 14:59

59 Even so, their testimony didn’t agree.
World English Bible

Meaning & historical commentary

Mark's trial scene is built on a courtroom that cannot make its case: Jewish law required that capital charges be sustained by witnesses whose accounts agreed, and here the Sanhedrin's hired accusers keep contradicting one another. The verse is the narrator's verdict on that failure, and it sets up the high priest's shift to a direct question, since the legal machinery has collapsed and only Jesus's own answer can carry the case forward. The English "agree" is reflected in the Greek word martyria, which in this setting denotes formal evidence given before a court, so the narrator is saying not merely that the gossip was inconsistent but that the proceeding had no valid testimony on which to stand.

Open in Interactive Book →