Verse study
Mark 14:19
19 They began to be sorrowful, and to ask him one by one, “Surely not I?” And another said, “Surely not I?”
Meaning & historical commentary
They begin to grieve and ask one by one, "Surely not I?", a question that shows the disciples are less confident in their own loyalty than in Jesus's word of warning. Around a shared meal in a reclining room, the disciples would have been close enough to hear and to be heard, so each man's question is spoken openly within the group rather than privately. Their repeated, self-doubting question, which the Greek phrasing expects a "no" answer to, reveals a circle of men who suspect they might be capable of such a betrayal, even as they cannot picture themselves doing it.