Verse study
Matthew 9:11
11 When the Pharisees saw it, they said to his disciples, “Why does your teacher eat with tax collectors and sinners?”
Meaning & historical commentary
The Pharisees' complaint lands in a house where the guests are exactly the people respectable Jewish society kept at arm's length: telones, tax-farmers who bought the right to collect revenue and were widely seen as collaborators with Rome, and "sinners," a loose label for those whose way of life was judged impure or dishonorable. Table fellowship was a public statement of who belonged, so the Pharisees, a group devoted to strict observance, are not merely puzzled but scandalized that a teacher would sit down with such company. Their question is aimed at the disciples, a way of pressing on Jesus through his followers, and it sets up his reply that the healthy need no physician.