Verse study

Matthew 27:23

23 But the governor said, “Why? What evil has he done?” But they cried out exceedingly, saying, “Let him be crucified!”
World English Bible

Meaning & historical commentary

Pilate, who has already concluded that Jesus is innocent, now tries to reason with a crowd that has stopped listening to reason, asking what crime the prisoner has actually committed. The crowd's reply is not an argument at all but a shout, and the Greek phrasing that describes it, meaning they cried out beyond all measure, paints a mob whose noise rises above the governor's questions and turns a legal hearing into a street disturbance. Pilate's concern about "a disturbance" in the previous verse is not abstract: at Passover, Jerusalem swelled with pilgrims, and a Roman governor who let a riot break out on a feast day could face serious trouble from Rome, which makes his eventual capitulation to the crowd's pressure understandable even as Matthew presents it as a failure of justice.

Open in Interactive Book →