Verse study
Matthew 26:8
8 But when his disciples saw this, they were indignant, saying, “Why this waste?
Meaning & historical commentary
The disciples' indignation at the woman's extravagance exposes a real tension in Jewish practice, where almsgiving to the poor was a sacred duty and a costly perfume poured out on a guest seemed to squander money that could have fed people. Their objection is not cruelty but piety shaped by the instinct to care for the poor, which is exactly why the rebuke that follows lands so hard. John's parallel names Judas as the voice behind the complaint, and the Mark parallel frames the critics as "some" among the group, so Matthew's plural "disciples" reads as a collective murmur that the narrative will soon sharpen into betrayal.