Verse study

Matthew 17:10

10 His disciples asked him, saying, “Then why do the scribes say that Elijah must come first?”
World English Bible

Meaning & historical commentary

The disciples' question is a scholar's question, the kind a student asks when a teacher's answer seems to contradict the text they have memorized. The scribes, the trained interpreters of Israel's Scriptures, taught from Malachi's promise that Elijah would come before the great day of the LORD, so the disciples, having just seen Elijah standing on the mountain with Jesus, want to know how the sequence fits together. Their wording, "then why," shows they are reasoning from what they have just witnessed back to what the experts have said, and that tension between expert tradition and personal experience is exactly what drives the rest of the exchange.

Open in Interactive Book →