Verse study
Luke 24:18
18 One of them, named Cleopas, answered him, “Are you the only stranger in Jerusalem who doesn’t know the things which have happened there in these days?”
Meaning & historical commentary
Cleopas and his companion are walking the seven-mile road from Jerusalem to Emmaus while Passover crowds are still in the city, and the stranger's question sounds almost absurd to them. Jerusalem in those days was swollen with pilgrims from across the empire, so anyone who had missed the crucifixion and the rumors about the empty tomb would have been a rare figure, and the word the Lukan text uses for "stranger" (paroikeo, to dwell as a sojourner) hints that a traveler living temporarily in the city would be expected to know its gossip. The question "are you the only one?" (monos, meaning sole or alone) stings with the irony of a man who has been the single person in the city who knows everything.