Verse study

Job 36:23

23 Who has prescribed his way for him? Or who can say, ‘You have committed unrighteousness’?
World English Bible

Meaning & historical commentary

Elihu's question is a rhetorical challenge aimed at Job and his friends, who have been demanding a verdict on God's conduct. In a legal world where a plaintiff brought charges before a court and a judge set the terms, no one could dictate God's course or summon him to a tribunal and name his fault. Elihu presses the point that the speaker of this poem cannot answer the question, so the accusation Job has been making against God has no standing. Scholars differ on how much weight this question carries against Job's own complaints, and the poem leaves that tension open rather than settling it.

Open in Interactive Book →