Verse study
Job 21:19
19 You say, ‘God lays up his iniquity for his children.’ Let him recompense it to himself, that he may know it.
Meaning & historical commentary
Job's friends have insisted that God stores up a wrongdoer's punishment and lets it fall on that man's descendants, and here Job turns the saying back on them with a sarcastic challenge: let God pay the sin back to the sinner himself, so that the man who did the wrong can see it happen. The sarcasm works because in a world where a family's fortunes were tied to its heirs, an inheritance of guilt was a familiar and bitter idea, and Job is ridiculing the idea that a sinner's own life is spared while his children bear the cost. Scholars debate whether the verb "lay up" in the friends' saying reflects a parent-child transfer of punishment or a more general reserving of wrath, and Job's reply answers whichever version they hold.