Verse study
Job 21:16
16 Behold, their prosperity is not in their hand. The counsel of the wicked is far from me.
Meaning & historical commentary
Job's reply here turns on a claim his friends would find shocking: that the wicked do not actually hold their good fortune in their own hands. In the ancient Near Eastern wisdom view that Job's friends defend, prosperity is the visible sign of a righteous life, so Job is pressing against a belief about how the world works rather than simply describing the rich. The second half, where the counsel of the wicked is "far from me," is Job distancing himself from their reasoning, which fits his claim in verse 15 that they dismiss God as irrelevant. Scholars debate exactly how the Hebrew of this line should be rendered, but its sense is clear: Job sees their success as fragile and unearned.