Verse study

Job 19:4

4 If it is true that I have erred, my error remains with myself.
World English Bible

Meaning & historical commentary

Job answers his friends in a courtroom-like exchange where to be "in the wrong" was a public, legal matter, and here he pushes the charge back onto himself: if he has gone astray, the consequence is his alone to carry. The phrase "my error remains with myself" (luwn, meaning to lodge or remain, is the same kind of stubborn staying-put) recasts the friends' accusation as something that cannot be shifted onto anyone else. Yet the sentence is conditional and rhetorical rather than a confession, so Job is not admitting guilt but challenging his interlocutors to prove what they claim, a move that sharpens the tension of the whole dialogue.

Open in Interactive Book →