Verse study
Job 15:3
3 Should he reason with unprofitable talk, or with speeches with which he can do no good?
Meaning & historical commentary
Eliphaz is accusing Job of talk that is all sound and no substance, the kind of argument that wins nothing and helps no one. In a world where wisdom was judged by its usefulness, where elders sat at the city gate and a good counsellor was valued for practical results, to call speech "unprofitable" is a sharp public charge, a claim that Job's words are wasted breath. Eliphaz uses the same vocabulary of profit and benefit that a merchant or a householder would understand, so the accusation lands as a judgment on Job's whole approach. The verse also sets up his larger strategy, since he portrays the debate itself as useless unless it leads to submission to traditional wisdom, a point the speaker presses hard in the lines that follow.