Verse study
John 9:28
28 They insulted him and said, “You are his disciple, but we are disciples of Moses.
Meaning & historical commentary
They insult the healed man by claiming discipleship to Moses as a badge of their own standing, drawing a hard line between the Pharisees' inherited identity and his new allegiance. In first-century Judea, a man's teacher defined his honor, and to be a mathetes of someone was to be bound to that master's authority and reputation. The Pharisees, who claimed to be students of the Law given through Moses, are essentially saying that their own pedigree is secure while his is borrowed from an upstart. The "we" carries the weight here: it is a deliberate contrast, not a casual pronoun, pitting the community that claims God's revelation against the man who has just been given sight by a teacher they refuse to recognize.