Verse study
John 9:2
2 His disciples asked him, “Rabbi, who sinned, this man or his parents, that he was born blind?”
Meaning & historical commentary
The disciples' question reflects a belief common in the ancient Jewish world that suffering was a direct consequence of personal or family sin, a idea the book of Job wrestles with at length. Their wording is pointed: they want to know whether the blindness was earned by this man before birth or by his parents, a question that would have sounded theologically tidy to them but deeply personal to a beggar whose condition marked him as an outsider. Interpreters differ on whether they were asking in genuine puzzlement or testing Jesus's view, and Luke 13:2 shows Jesus rejecting the same assumption about the Galileans who suffered.