Verse study
John 8:5
5 Now in our law, Moses commanded us to stone such women. What then do you say about her?”
Meaning & historical commentary
The scribes and Pharisees are not asking a neutral legal question here: they are staging a trap that pits Jesus's loyalty to Moses against his reputation for mercy. Moses's law in Deuteronomy 22 and Leviticus 20 prescribes death by stoning for adultery, so the question forces a choice between defying the Torah and contradicting the compassion he has been known for. The phrase "such women" points to a whole category of offenders rather than this one woman alone, which sharpens the dilemma: a ruling for or against her becomes a ruling about the law itself.