Verse study

John 8:17

17 It’s also written in your law that the testimony of two people is valid.
World English Bible

Meaning & historical commentary

Jesus here appeals to a principle the Pharisees themselves cite, the requirement of multiple witnesses before a charge can stand in a legal case, and he turns it back on them. In a Jewish courtroom a lone testimony could not convict, and the Deuteronomy passages make the rule explicit: a matter is established at the mouth of two witnesses, and a capital charge cannot rest on one. Jesus is reasoning inside the very legal framework his opponents have just invoked, which is why his claim to have a second witness, the Father, lands as a deliberate counter to their objection in verse 13 that he testifies alone. The audience hearing this in the Temple precincts would recognize the argument as a courtroom move, an appeal to the law rather than a mystical assertion.

Open in Interactive Book →