Verse study
John 16:5
5 But now I am going to him who sent me, and none of you asks me, ‘Where are you going?’
Meaning & historical commentary
Jesus has just told his disciples he is leaving, and this verse rests on a striking reversal: they are sorrowful at the news, yet none of them has asked where he is going. In the ancient world a teacher's departure was a grave matter, and a student would naturally press the master for direction, as Peter later does in a similar moment when he asks where Jesus is going and receives an answer that cuts both ways. Here the silence is the problem, since the disciples are absorbed in their grief rather than in the destination of the one who is leaving, which lets Jesus frame his coming departure as something they have failed to grasp rather than simply endure.