Verse study

Jeremiah 23:18

18 For who has stood in the council of Yahweh, that he should perceive and hear his word? Who has listened to my word, and heard it?
World English Bible

Meaning & historical commentary

Jeremiah's question is rhetorical and pointed: the prophets who promise peace claim to have access to Yahweh's inner deliberations, yet none of them has been where the decisions are made. In the courtly imagery of the ancient Near East, a king's council was a closed session of trusted advisers who heard the decision before the people did, and a prophet who truly stood in that room would have something real to announce. The Hebrew sod in this setting denotes such an intimate assembly, so the question shifts from "who has prophesied" to "who has been admitted to the decision." Jeremiah's original audience, living under Babylonian pressure and tempted by reassuring voices, is being told that the rival messages of comfort carry no credentials of access to Yahweh's word.

Open in Interactive Book →