Verse study
Jeremiah 16:10
10 It will happen, when you tell this people all these words, and they ask you, ‘Why has Yahweh pronounced all this great evil against us?’ or ‘What is our iniquity?’ or ‘What is our sin that we have committed against Yahweh our God?’
Meaning & historical commentary
Jeremiah's listeners are being prepared for a question they are certain to ask, and the prophet is told in advance what his answer must be. The people, cut off by siege and exile, will want to know what they did to deserve such a catastrophe, and the question itself reveals how they understood their relationship with Yahweh: disaster needed a cause, and the cause had to be a debt. Their asking is also an admission that they expected the deity to act in a way they could follow, through a clear chain of offense and punishment. Jeremiah's reply, given in the next verse, will refuse their innocence by pointing back to the fathers, which is why this scripted question matters so much as the hinge of the whole exchange.