Verse study
Judges 21:3
3 They said, “Yahweh, the God of Israel, why has this happened in Israel, that there should be one tribe lacking in Israel today?”
Meaning & historical commentary
The verse is a lament spoken by the whole assembly, and its force lies in the question's theology: Israel's grief is aimed at Yahweh himself, asking why a tribe has been lost from the covenant community. The people are not confessing guilt here so much as baffled at a disaster they themselves set in motion by their oath at Mizpah, and the wording "lacking" (paqad) carries the sense of something missing that should have been accounted for, as when a muster of troops comes up short. In a society with no king to adjudicate such a crisis, appealing directly to God at Bethel, where they wept until evening, was the only court of last resort the tribes possessed.