Verse study

Judges 21:15

15 The people grieved for Benjamin, because Yahweh had made a breach in the tribes of Israel.
World English Bible

Meaning & historical commentary

The grief in this verse is not sentimental. The tribes have just destroyed Jabesh Gilead and taken its women to rescue Benjamin, and the people now mourn because the breach is theirs: Yahweh has made a perets, a break, in the tribal fabric of Israel, and a tribe that was whole is now missing a piece. The "breach" language suggests a torn wall or a gap in a structure that was supposed to hold together, so the tribes are confronting what their own oath and their own war have cost them. Scholars differ on whether the narrator presents this grief as sincere repentance or as an ironic exposure of a community that has made the situation its own fault.

Open in Interactive Book →