Verse study
Judges 20:9
9 But now this is the thing which we will do to Gibeah: we will go up against it by lot;
Meaning & historical commentary
The tribes have sworn an oath to leave Gibeah unpunished by none of them, so they resolve to decide by lot which of their own men will march against the town, a method that puts the whole nation's violence in the hands of chance rather than any single leader. Casting lots was a recognized way of seeking a divine verdict in the ancient Near East, and Israel's own sacred practice used it, which is why the people treat the outcome as a kind of sacred sorting rather than a random draw. Yet the verse also shows a community without a king or central authority trying to organize a punitive war through shared consent, with the lot serving to make the choice seem impartial to every tribe involved.