Verse study

Judges 20:12

12 The tribes of Israel sent men through all the tribe of Benjamin, saying, “What wickedness is this that has happened among you?
World English Bible

Meaning & historical commentary

The tribes send envoys into Benjamin's territory with a blunt question, and the wording matters: they ask what zoth, this wickedness, has happened among you, treating the crime at Gibeah as a matter for the whole nation rather than for one town. In a society with no king and no central court, such an appeal had to travel tribe to tribe through local leaders and elders, which means Israel's unity was being tested through messengers rather than through any formal authority. Benjamin's own tribe is named in the same breath as the crime, so the question is not only what happened but whose responsibility it is; the tribes are asking Benjamin to answer for its own people before the rest of Israel decides what to do.

Open in Interactive Book →