Verse study
Isaiah 49:24
24 Shall the plunder be taken from the mighty, or the lawful captives be delivered?
Meaning & historical commentary
The question is a rhetorical one put in the mouth of Zion's exiles, who assume that a conqueror's grip on captives is as unbreakable as a wild animal's jaws on its prey. In the Babylonian period, deportees were marched across the desert to Mesopotamia and settled in colonies, and a people taken this way had little reason to expect release, since empires kept hold of their booty and the lives they had taken. The prophet voices the despairing logic of the captive community, which sees no lawful way to undo a seizure carried out by the mighty. The verse therefore frames the coming reply as a direct challenge to that assumption, and the next verse answers that even the captives of the mighty will be taken away.