Verse study
Isaiah 41:28
28 When I look, there is no man, even among them there is no counselor who, when I ask, can answer a word.
Meaning & historical commentary
When the Judean audience heard God ask who among the idols or their makers could answer, they were hearing a courtroom challenge. In a world where kings and cities consulted seers, astrologers, and temple oracles before any campaign, the prophet imagines Yahweh scanning the assembled nations, looking for a single counselor who could explain past events or foretell what comes next. The silence is the point: the gods of the nations, unlike Yahweh, cannot speak into history, which makes this an argument aimed at exiles tempted to think Babylon's deities had won.