Verse study
Isaiah 22:2
2 You that are full of shouting, a tumultuous city, a joyous town, your slain are not slain with the sword, neither are they dead in battle.
Meaning & historical commentary
Jerusalem in this oracle is a city of noise and festivity at the very moment it should be mourning, and the crowd that has spilled onto the rooftops is cheering while its soldiers have already fled. The city's own roar, hamah, is the sound of a crowd in commotion, the same clamor that fills a city square on a feast day, so the prophet is describing a party in full swing while the enemy presses at the gates. The shock lies in the phrase "your slain are not slain with the sword": the dead are not battlefield casualties at all, which suggests the bloodshed has come from within the city, or from famine and flight, and listeners who expected a heroic defense would have heard that as a bitter inversion.