Verse study
Hosea 9:2
2 The threshing floor and the wine press won’t feed them, and the new wine will fail her.
Meaning & historical commentary
The grain threshing floor and the wine vat were the hard-earned heart of an agrarian village, the places where a year's harvest was turned into food and drink. Hosea is saying that the very installations that were supposed to sustain Israel will fail it, and the verb for that failure is a sharp one: kachash carries the sense of being untrue, of a promise made and then broken, so the new wine that should flow in autumn will betray its drinkers. The audience, living in a northern kingdom that credited Baal with its fertility, would have heard the pointed irony that the grain and grape gods they served could not deliver what they promised.