Verse study

Genesis 43:7

7 They said, “The man asked directly concerning ourselves, and concerning our relatives, saying, ‘Is your father still alive? Have you another brother?’ We just answered his questions. Is there any way we could know that he would say, ‘Bring your brother down’?”
World English Bible

Meaning & historical commentary

The brothers' defense here is a lawyer's careful reconstruction, and the detail that gives it away is how fully the questions had been asked. In the ancient Near East, a traveler from a foreign land passing through a border-controlled economy would be questioned on his origins and family, and the brothers insist they did nothing more than answer exactly what they were asked, down to whether they had another brother. Their point is that the disclosure was the official's doing, not their scheme, and that no one could have foreseen the demand for Benjamin. Readers who remember the earlier interrogation would hear the bitter irony of the rhetorical question at its end: they now cannot see the trap they walked into, even as the reader knows Joseph engineered it.

Open in Interactive Book →