Verse study
Genesis 38:10
10 The thing which he did was evil in Yahweh’s sight, and he killed him also.
Meaning & historical commentary
Judah's sons Er and Onan both die, and this verse hangs their deaths on Onan's conduct, which Yahweh judges as evil in his sight. The author has just shown Onan refusing to raise up offspring for his dead brother, and now the narrative names that refusal as the cause of his death, with the Hebrew for "evil" (raa) signaling something that spoils and ruins the household's future rather than a mere private failing. In a clan where a man's line and inheritance were tied to the land of Canaan, Onan's deliberate spilling of seed to deny Er a son would have struck the original audience as a hostile act against the family itself, which is why the story treats it as a capital offense.