Verse study
Ezekiel 17:9
9 “Say, ‘The Lord Yahweh says: “Will it prosper? Won’t he pull up its roots and cut off its fruit, that it may wither, that all its fresh springing leaves may wither? It can’t be raised from its roots by a strong arm or many people.
Meaning & historical commentary
Ezekiel's allegory now turns from the eagle's planting to the rhetorical question that the exiles are meant to answer for themselves: a vine taken from good soil and set down among strangers cannot be expected to thrive. Judean agriculture depended on the careful tending of vines, and a vine lifted from its ground would have its roots torn and its shoots left to dry, so the question carries the weight of an obvious agricultural fact. The rhetoric is pointed at the audience, who were living in Babylon and wondering whether Zedekiah's kingdom could survive by pinning its hopes on Egypt; the answer assumed in the question is that such a plant will not prosper once its roots are disturbed.