Verse study
Exodus 8:32
32 Pharaoh hardened his heart this time also, and he didn’t let the people go.
Meaning & historical commentary
Pharaoh's reversal here follows a pattern the text sets up deliberately: relief arrives, and the king's response is to dig in rather than yield. The phrase "this time also" marks a cycle, a ruler who promises release when the plague is upon him and retracts once it lifts, the way a court might grant a petition under pressure and then rescind it when the pressure passes. The narrator is careful to name Pharaoh's own choice as the cause, a theme developed again when Exodus 4:21 announces that God would harden the king's heart, which makes the reader weigh divine and human agency together.