Verse study

Exodus 5:17

17 But Pharaoh said, “You are idle! You are idle! Therefore you say, ‘Let’s go and sacrifice to Yahweh.’
World English Bible

Meaning & historical commentary

Pharaoh's answer is a sharp reversal: the Israelites' request for a three-day festival in the wilderness is recast as laziness, the one charge a labor-driven state would find most intolerable. In an Egyptian building economy where a gang's output was counted in bricks and enforced by overseers with rods, idleness was not a moral failing but a threat to the whole project, so the accusation doubles as a justification for harsher quotas. The repeated "You are idle!" stings because it turns the people's appeal to their God into proof that they have too much free time, and scholars debate whether the account reflects a specific reign or a stylized literary picture of Egyptian bondage.

Open in Interactive Book →