Verse study
2 Samuel 3:11
11 He could not answer Abner another word, because he was afraid of him.
Meaning & historical commentary
Abner's silence here is a turning point: the most powerful man in Ishbosheth's court, the commander who actually held the northern kingdom together, has just been publicly rebuked over a woman who belonged to the dead king Saul, and the claim to that harem was a claim to the throne itself. In a world where a new ruler took possession of his predecessor's wives, Abner's answer would have settled the succession, so Ishbosheth's inability to reply reveals how thoroughly the weak son of Saul depends on the general who makes him king. The fear is not a private nerve but a political fact: the house of Saul now lacks the power to confront its own commander.