Verse study
2 Samuel 18:11
11 Joab said to the man who told him, “Behold, you saw it, and why didn’t you strike him there to the ground? I would have given you ten pieces of silver and a sash.”
Meaning & historical commentary
Joab's question is not really about the man's marksmanship but about a soldier's expected loyalty: in a battle that has just ended, a fighter who sees the rebel prince hanging helpless in a tree and does nothing has failed the commander who needs Absalom dead. Joab's offer of ten pieces of silver and a sash, a military belt or ornamented girdle, shows how a commander would reward a decisive kill, and the reward is a sharp contrast to the king's order that Absalom be spared. The word for "why" in Joab's question, madduwa, can carry a sense of "what is known?", so Joab is incredulous that the man should know exactly what to do and yet hold back.