Verse study
1 Samuel 28:16
16 Samuel said, “Why then do you ask me, since Yahweh has departed from you and has become your adversary?
Meaning & historical commentary
Samuel's reply turns Saul's request for a word from the dead into a verdict: a king who has lost God's answer through prophets and dreams now finds that the one voice he hoped to reach from beyond the grave brings only the same judgment. Saul has done the very thing he had outlawed, consulting a medium at Endor after purging the land of such practitioners, and the scene makes plain that the appeal to the dead cannot reopen a door that Yahweh has closed. The shock for the original audience lies in the phrase "has become your adversary," since the ordinary word for foe carries the sense of one watching for mischief, so the king who sought divine counsel finds himself facing the very God who had once stood with him.