Verse study
1 Samuel 23:3
3 David’s men said to him, “Behold, we are afraid here in Judah. How much more then if we go to Keilah against the armies of the Philistines?”
Meaning & historical commentary
The men's fear is blunt and practical: they are a band of roughly six hundred fugitives already hiding in Judah, and David is proposing to march them out of the wilderness into a walled town to fight a Philistine army. Judah was the territory of the house of Saul's own tribe and the place where a price was on David's head, so the men are reasoning that every step outside the hills increases their exposure to Saul's forces as well as to the Philistines. Their question, "How much more then," turns on the contrast between "here" and the open field of battle, and it shows an audience already accustomed to the idea that David's movements were measured by the risk of being caught.