Verse study

1 Samuel 2:23

23 He said to them, “Why do you do such things? For I hear of your evil dealings from all these people.
World English Bible

Meaning & historical commentary

Eli's rebuke lands in a world where a priest's word carried the weight of the sanctuary itself, and where he speaks to sons who have made the Shiloh sacrifices into a private larder. Israelite worshippers came to the central shrine expecting the sacred meal to be shared before Yahweh, so the sons' taking of the best meat by force turned an act of communion into open contempt for the people's offerings. Eli's question, "Why do you do such things?", pushes past mere disapproval, since the phrase ra (evil) names deeds that harm the community as much as they offend God, and his appeal to the public talk about them shows that the scandal had already become common knowledge across the tribes.

Open in Interactive Book →